Do we know if we are spiritual? Yes, in the sense that being spiritual is our natural and created vocation. We are made for relationships with one another, with all creation, with God in and through everything else, and even ourselves. We have the capacity and are oriented for a spiritual walk in life, and the longing for this is constant though we may not realize what that longing is. As Augustine stated, we are relentless until we rest in God.
However, do we know if we are spiritual in the sense of being aware of how much we have grown into our rightful nature? Is it even necessary that we know? I don’t think so, because nothing is gained by knowing where we are on the journey, and much harm can come from believing we can or should know.
The admonition to not judge (Matthew 7:1) is typically understood as a prohibition against sizing up others, but does it not also apply as a warning against self-evaluation?
But to me it is a very small thing that I may be examined by you, or by any human court; in fact, I do not even examine myself. 1 Corinthians 4:3
Paul says he does not examine or judge himself. He goes on to say that it is the Lord who can do that, and urges the Corinthians to leave that to God. Bonhoeffer cautioned, in Life Together, against constantly taking our spiritual temperature.

I doubt that we make any spiritual progress by attempting to monitor our spiritual “level” or “state” at any given time. This focus is actually detrimental to our formation, leading to comparisons with others, pride or discouragement, and is a distraction from fixing our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of our faith (Hebrews 12:2).
And He was saying, “The kingdom of God is like a man who casts seed the soil; And he goes to bed at night and gets up by day, and the seed sprouts and grows—how, he himself does not know. Mark 4:26-27
Our spiritual formation is the mystery of God’s own activity of grace. We enjoy a “hidden” spirituality because we do not know what happens or exactly how, and the increase is given as God wills. We must trust the process and that it unfolds according to God’s wisdom. What is hidden to us is open to God, and this is best.
If we concentrate too intently on the movement within us trying to measure and evaluate it, when it is not ours to control, nor can we cause the changes to occur, we may be less inclined to simply relax into what God is doing in us through His Spirit. Fists clenched in stout resolve are not as helpful as open hands which are ready to receive. Furthermore, what we are given may surprise us, at least to some degree.
To simply be present in the moment, to be as we are, naked and unassuming before God, is the posture of the humble. We need to focus on our “being” before God. To worry less about our “becoming” is one way to be ready for the actual “becoming” that is happening. Whatever formation the Spirit is affecting in us is not in the future, but in the sacred moment of now.
